
Premium feel at a budget-friendly price.

Winner
The ecobee New Smart Thermostat Premium stands out in the smart thermostat market, especially for users seeking effective humidity control and energy savings. One of its big advantages is the SmartSensor, which helps manage temperature and eliminate hot or cold spots, enhancing comfort across rooms. It also boasts a built-in air quality monitor that not only alerts users to poor air quality but also offers actionable tips for improvement.
In terms of compatibility, this thermostat works with various smart home systems, including Apple HomeKit, Amazon Alexa, and Google Assistant, making it flexible for users with different setups. The vibrant display and user-friendly interface are further positives, making it easy to navigate and control.
However, there are some drawbacks. The need for an Apple Home Hub to enable Siri can limit its appeal for non-Apple users. Additionally, certain advanced features, like alerts for open doors or windows, require a subscription to the ecobee Smart Security plan, which may deter budget-conscious users. While the device is compatible with most HVAC systems, installation can still be challenging for those without a C-Wire, despite the included Power Extender Kit. The ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium is a great choice for tech-savvy users looking to optimize their home’s heating and cooling while maintaining good air quality, but it may pose challenges for those less familiar with smart home setups or those looking for a more budget-friendly option.
The Google Nest Learning Thermostat (4th Gen) stands out as a top choice in the smart thermostat category, especially for those looking to manage their home's temperature and humidity efficiently. Its compatibility with various heating and cooling systems makes it versatile for most homes. The inclusion of the Nest Temperature Sensor further enhances its capability to address temperature variances in different rooms, ideal for larger spaces or homes with specific comfort needs.
One of the key strengths of this thermostat is its energy-saving features. With the ability to learn your preferences and automatically adjust temperatures, it can help save an average of 12% on heating and 15% on cooling bills. The Adaptive Eco feature is particularly valuable, as it finds energy-efficient settings based on external temperatures.
The user interface is intuitive and visually appealing, thanks to a large, bright display that adjusts for optimum visibility. Integration with smart home systems like Google Home and Alexa makes it easy to control through voice commands or the app. Installation is user-friendly, typically taking around 40 minutes, which is a plus for DIY enthusiasts.
There are a few drawbacks to consider. While the thermostat is designed to work with many systems, some users may still need a C wire for compatibility, which could complicate installation in certain setups. Additionally, while it includes humidity control features, it does not provide as detailed humidity management as some more specialized thermostats might.
The design and functionality receive high praise, though the price point may be a concern for budget-conscious buyers. Despite these minor drawbacks, the Google Nest Learning Thermostat (4th Gen) represents a solid investment for anyone looking to enhance home comfort while reducing energy costs.
The Honeywell Home X8S Smart Thermostat is a strong choice if you want a thermostat that goes beyond just temperature control. It offers good compatibility with many heating and cooling systems, including heat pumps and conventional setups, although it does not support electric baseboard heating. One standout feature is its built-in humidity and ventilation control, helping maintain better indoor air quality, which is a bit rare in smart thermostats. The included wireless Room Sensor improves comfort by allowing targeted temperature adjustments in different rooms and has a long range for flexible placement. Its 5-inch customizable touchscreen is easy to read and lets you personalize colors and styles to fit your home’s look.
For smart home fans, it works well with Alexa, Google Assistant, Apple Home, and is Matter certified, making it easy to integrate with many devices. The ability to see and talk to visitors on compatible video doorbells right from the thermostat adds useful convenience, especially for home security. Remote control through the First Alert app means you can manage settings from anywhere. It also includes energy-saving features, supports programs and rebates, and comes ENERGY STAR certified.
Some advanced air quality features require additional HVAC equipment, so you might need extra gear to get the full benefit. It also requires a C-wire for installation, though the package includes a voucher for an adapter if needed. Learning capabilities are handled through occupancy and presence detection rather than traditional adaptive scheduling, which works well but might not suit everyone looking for a fully self-learning thermostat. This thermostat is well-suited for users wanting a smart, connected device with strong humidity control and air quality features, combined with useful extras like video doorbell integration and flexible room sensing.